My Art Dilemma

I unpacked my art recently, just to make sure all was safe and not damaged from the six months that they spent boxed and mostly on a ship and now, in my cellar in a very dry space. I pulled out my paintings and felt a huge sense of relief to see that all were in perfect shape. Yay! This makes me very, very happy. But this is not my art dilemma...

going through my paintings

Above you can view some original works by American artist Jennifer Davis. Jennifer is amazing. I own eight original paintings by her, five are shown. I love her work, though I wish so many were not orange because I am not at all a fan of orange these days. I don't think I ever was, but I went through this orange phase for a few years and these paintings were part of that phase. And another thing when it comes to other paintings I own -- I don't know where to display them or what to do with art that I no longer relate to - work that does not match my design aesthetic or home. Not the ones shown but some I have still in storage. They worked for me once but no longer feel like a fit. Could be because I live in a different part of the world with different light and in a new landscape. My art collection values at around $10,000 USD or slightly more - not including prints and limited edition work. That's a lot of money spent on paintings that I don't know what to do with! I love my artist friends and though some of this work I will keep because I do have a connection... for instance in the photo above I will most likely display three of them when I move and have the wall space. So I ask... what does one do with art that they no longer relate to? What would you do? Do you think it would offend the artist if I sold some of it? What do I do with original work that I no longer feel a connection to - perhaps the colors or imagery or other? Just because it doesn't suit me doesn't mean someone else wouldn't adore it as I once did. Thoughts? (image: holly becker)

Comments

jja said…
I would donate this to library, Arztpraxis (probably to my Hausarzt) or to somebody who wants art and can not afford like single mother or so...or just sell them, why not? You also paid for this.
Aw, I see your concern. I don't know if it would be offendent to sell them but you may find it difficult to be separate from something your hearted for so long, isn't it ?

Anyway, if you decide to sell some of your art, tell me, I'm currently looking for original prints ! ;-)
Allison said…
I'm trying not to think about my stuff on a ship. I'm so worried it's all going to show up smashed to bits.

As for the art, I think if you don't feel it's making a positive impact in your home, then you should sell it to a new home. Not sure the best way to do that, though.
Unknown said…
If you have space, store it. You loved it once; maybe you'll love it again, or maybe you'll have a new space that needs something you haven't seen in a while.

On the other hand, if you don't have space, sell it or give it away. Artists, like gift-givers, don't really get a say once it's left their hands, and as long as the art (or gift) is not being mutilated or abused I don't see a right to offense.

As clutter goes, art at least stacks tidily in storage. ::grin::
V said…
I'm interested to see what others post! I feel terrible that some of the prints I've bought in the past couple years no longer speak to me. I wonder if the things I bought were too trendy or something; now I'm a bit afraid to trust my current taste, too! Is it natural to grow out of art or am I buying wrong?
Anonymous said…
Save just the ones you still like and give the others to friends or sell them. Just because something is labeled as "art", that does not mean you have to worship it.

What would you do with a skirt that does not fit over your hips or into your wardrope anymore? Would you keep it for years just because you did not buy it at a chain store, but because somebody made it by hand and sold it via Etsy? Probably you would get rid of it.

Allow yourself to let go!

I have similar dilemmas sometimes with things, especially when they seem unique. But a house crowded with stuff from your past usually doesnt make you happy.
I think that nothing is wrong if you decide to sell or give those paintings away. People are way too much attached to things and that makes us unhappy. We should let them go. It's hard to learn, but we should ... at least try. And it is normal that you would like another paintings as well as new bag or dress. I paint myself and I also change my paintings from time to time, I keep them in a closet or give them away ... others are always happy about it.
Sonja said…
I don't see a problem by selling art, you don't want to "use" anymore. Unless the artist isn't one of your best friends or something like that.

These paintings are beautiful and there could be many new homes for them, where they would be appreciated. :)
labyrinthine said…
If you have the space, I'd say guest room, but if not, selling it or gifting it would be a wonderful alternative. I adore those originals by Jennifer Davis (I love her work as well), and I couldn't conceive of selling them, but I understand outgrowing something or simply wanting a new look - especially when your design aesthetics have changed so much. And I'm sure there are many people who would love to have them!
Unknown said…
I agree with previous posters - if you have the space to store it and think you'll love it again someday, keep it. If not, gift it or sell it, being sure to include a little note about who the artist is.

If it were my work, I might be a little sad, but honestly I want my things to be with people who LOVE them. AND, by gifting or selling the pieces, you're introducing new people to the work - maybe sparking the interest of the next avid collector.
Anke Weckmann said…
ask her openly if she would mind. (She'll probably see this post anyway!).
Maybe you can swap with a friend who has other art they would like to swap for.
Kara said…
I don't see a problem with selling art you no longer relate too! It seems silly to keep something hidden away that's meant to be displayed, especially when there's probably someone else out there who would love to have it on show right now.
Lanne said…
If you sold the work two things would happen - You would have more money to spend on art. Someone else woudl now be enjoying a painting/print you had loved. Now that piece was loved not once but twice. And new work found a home. Collections need to be loved. Otherwise they are clutter. As an artist I would be more upset if my work was in storage.
Alissa said…
I like the idea of donating it. But, I don't think it's a big deal to sell it either.

I like the artwork a lot - so I'm sure you'll be able to find a loving home for it.
shanon said…
I don't think there is anything wrong with selling it to someone else, because I'm sure the artist would want it in the home of someone who loves and appreciates it, and displays it. If it doesn't "do it" for you anymore, you should give someone else the opportunity to enjoy them. Besides, not even the great masterpieces of the world have stayed in the collection of one person their whole life. Art is meant to move and flow and influence. Sell what you need to, it seems like it's making you feel guilty right now, and that's not good.
Eva said…
I would not see a problem in selling some of your collection. You will create new finances to buy new art, yes?
Lizardo said…
I would donate or sell the works. Speaking as an artist, there is work I have done that no longer speaks to me. It is something from the past, so I would understand a collector feeling the same way.
Anonymous said…
As an artist I go through phases in my art and also what I enjoy in my home-I would never be offended if someone who owned my work outgrew it. If it sat in a dark closet or got pitched in the dustbin then maybe I would but if one took the effort to make sure it went to someone who enjoyed it then it is a win/win-I would have two happy clients instead of one.
Trades are always a good idea too-I do this with other artists. When we get tired of something or just want a change a good swap always does the trick!
Laura C said…
Don't feel bad Holly! Our tastes change through the years and it's better to hold on to something because you love it, instead of because you feel guilty. Instead of putting them back in a box somewhere, sell them or regift them so they can be enjoyed by another. :)
ethanollie said…
my first original painting purchase is hanging in my dining room (much to my dismay). like you, i just don't 'feel it' anymore.

so i agree. maybe put them aside until you move into your new space then try a few there. if you still aren't connecting...sell them.

i'm sure an artist would rather their work be hanging and loved in the home of someone else, than stored away.
mary said…
I really appreciate your honesty here! I thought I was the only one who went through decorating phases and it's good to see that those with impeccable, well-honed taste do, too. :)

I really agree with Virginia's thoughts...after spending money on art I no longer connect with, I'm almost afraid to buy art I currently love. I'm afraid my tastes will change again.

I hope you find a way to pass on the art you no longer want; I would imagine that maybe a local gallery or maybe even eBay would be a good way to do this? Or, give pieces as gifts to friends who would love them. Even if you don't get money for all of the pieces you want to part with, at least knowing they are going to a good home would leave you with a really good feeling.
The Designer said…
We all have beautiful things that seemingly do not fit into our homes anymore! I sometimes give great pieces to a few of my relatives that have shown an interest or I would sell what I know I would not use. But several pieces together still makes a great grouping and maybe you have somewhere in your new home to place an interesting grouping. Or new idea...have an art trade with others in your community!
Anonymous said…
They are lovely!
But i do understand what you mean..
I beleive things are ment to be used, thats there purpose as objects. If they dont suit you, give them new life by any of the ways you mentioned
Evelyn said…
I've had this same experience in the past with original work from artist friends of mine. Some of it still works for me, other pieces do not. I've never sold it (because it doesn't take up much space to store it) but I have contacted the artists to see if they would like the opportunity to buy it back before selling it to someone else. For me, it was a matter of respect to the person who created it (who knows, maybe they want to add it back to their collection!) Either way, if you don't want to display it in your home any longer, don't hold onto it. I would almost guarantee someone out there would love to add those pieces to their collections.
Anonymous said…
People sell many other things, furniture, porcelain, books etc., so why not sell the art? There are auctions where you can afford a good price, sometimes bigger then you paid for them. And then you can buy something you really enjoy now. Keeping things that just don't work anymore is a dead capital.
Jessie said…
I'm having the same dilemma - some of the pieces of art that I bought in my last home don't necessarily work in my new home, and some pieces I'm just "over". Some of them are just prints, but the money still adds up... I wonder what an artist would think if they saw their own piece for sale by someone other than themselves or their representative? Are you allowed to make money on it, or just recoup what you spent? If you find out the etiquette, or a venue for selling these pieces (is ebay a no -no?), please share your findings!
Ann Marie said…
Interesting topic Holly. My first thought was to donate the art to a non-profit that might benefit from auctioning it off to raise money. Two good things come from this...giving to charity and sending more art out into the world. Another thought, was to gift some to friends who may have admired a particular piece. Perhaps they can't afford original art right now. You would make their day, let them know they are special to you, and that the art itself is special too.

I'm not sure how one would go about selling original art they bought from the artist. I would think some artists wouldn't mind, but think others might. Do you charge what you paid for it? If less, how much less? I curious to see what feedback you get.

I too get bored (so to speak) with art after several years. I usually just store it a while until it looks fresh to me again. Or work into another part of my home.
iva yaneva said…
I think that an artist would prefer if their art was displayed, even not by the original owner, rather than sitting in boxes. Perhaps if you organized a sale or a swap or something like that, explaining why you are doing this and that the art just doesn't correspond to your home decor any more and you would love it if others display it, the artists wouldn't feel bat about that, even the opposite. It means that you care enough for their art to be looking for a new better home for their pieces.
That's what I think at least :)
Null said…
In terms of selling, you should be less concerned with offending the artist than helping his or her career. If you do sell them, place them in the best hands possible. By doing so, you're contributing to the dissemination of their work and the possibility of gaining them a reputation.
Dawn said…
i agree with gwen. i was actually going to type the exact same words. tastes change often, but if it is good taste you'll more than likely rediscover how you initially felt about them in the future. i have a couple of pieces myself that i am no longer attached to, but am holding onto them just incase :)

i don't think it is offensive to sell the art if you no longer have the space or need for them too.
Unknown said…
That is a tough one! I have some silimar pieces {including ones that were gifts, and were never to my taste}.

If you have large/higher priced items you haven't enjoyed in years I'd look at reselling {and reinvesting in new pieces, yay!}. If the artist is known they are likely to have a following who may be looking for some of their earlier works!

If they're smaller {easier to store} and you've loved them for a long time, I'd consider keeping them and revisiting them in a few years - as your decor style/tastes are likely to change again!
Helen, UK said…
I change my art/photos around in my house all the time. I have a box which I store them in when not 'in use'. Some days I fancy taking it all down and living a day with nothing on the walls, other days I just move pieces from one room to another. For months I only want photos up, other months, just my own art. I say - keep. We love things in cycles and the beauty of art is how it expresses what is inside each of us.
Vanessa said…
I'm a big fan of practicality... if it doesn't work, sell it, donate it, or give it to a friend who would enjoy it. I'm sure the artist would rather have the piece gracing someone else's wall rather than collecting dust in a closet!
Tammy said…
If you someday have a daughter, I'm sure hew jaw would drop when you brought your beautiful collection out of storage. Then you could see it on her apartment walls and she could pass it down as well. Maybe you could save half of your collection? The ones that mean the most. I know I would ::flip:: if my mom pulled out her favorite peices from the time that I was just a twinkle in her eye.
Berlinquilter said…
I think giving away your art shouldn´t be a problem for you.One one hand I am sure there are many people interested (either as a gift or sold), and on the other hand I think it is so important to let things go which don´t suit you anymore. Then there will be more space for new things aswell (Feng Shui also says that...;-))
Peggy said…
Interesting dilemma, Holly. I am a painter so I can relate to changing tastes. There are many interesting points to be made here.

Once I was head over heels in love with my brother's (also a painter) art work and I had it all over my house. His works were very jarring and one day I wanted a softer touch in my home. I replaced his paintings with my own. He was horribly hurt and I felt terrible.

I've had the same experience. I have given paintings to family and they've ended up smashed into closets with the gifts they didn't like. Still, tastes change.

Art is meant to be viewed and loved, not smashed into a closet.
Please pass these along to someone who will love them. It pains me to think of them in a closet. I like jja's comment about donationg them. (Except for the Jennifer Davis painting of a girl, which should be mailed to me immediately. :) Maybe you can auction them off and donate the money to Haiti?

Are you familiar with the term Indian giver? We usually use that term as a negative, but it is actually a positive thing. The Native Americans believed that possessions should remain dynamic. To hoard stagnates the flow of energy. When they gave settlers gifts and it pained them when gifts were hoarded and not used. When one person is done with something, they should let it move to someone who can use or love it. The Natives tried to show the settlers this and were misunderstood.

Perhaps we should be careful not to buy art that is so trendy. However, it's important to support artists. Have you asked your artist friends their thoughts on this?

Lastly, it is important to note that art can stand alone and doesn't have to match decor.

Sorry for going on and on. I will look forward to other comments on this post. I will also look forward to how you resolve this issue. Take care.
Renate said…
I completely agree with the previous commenters. It's fine to sell or gift a piece of art that you no longer love.
Maybe put it up on eBay or kijiji.de?
You should sell it, and you should not feel guilty about doing so. Art is bought and sold all the time. Christie's is well known for their fine art auctions. If the artist is a friend, just explain it to them as you have here. I too would rather see art admired and loved rather than stored in a closet or attic. As you said, just because it doesn't speak to you doesn't mean it will not be adored by someone else.
Juliette said…
This is exactly why I have always had the hardest time committing to purchasing art! I know I'll get to this point and then what?!

I like CluelessCrafter's point about making it a positive thing for the artist in the sell/trade/donate phase.

I once hosted 2 massive paintings 'on loan' for a couple of years from an artist friend. He said he'd give me a commission if I sold them. Maybe you have a friend who can host them for you that will enjoy them more and give you a cut if they sell them? (or decide to purchase one themselves)
Gilby said…
What is your goal with buying art? If it is to supplement your current decor (aka "sofa paintings"), then purchase with the knowledge that you will tire of it and have no guilt when you get rid of it. There are artists who make work primarily for this purpose, and there are artists who might be a bit insulted that their labor of love is being purchased only because it matches the customer's sofa or bedspread.

I would rather buy fewer pieces that I know will speak to me for a long time, knowing I will always make space for it. I have some blank walls in the meantime, but no regrets!
Yoli said…
Personally I would store it for a while. You don't know when a piece might fit a mood. If they are really getting in the way and you don't think they will excite you again, then I would sell them.
Peggy said…
Holly - I'd like to say one more quick thing from a painter's perspective. Everyone here is correct about letting go, but we must remember we are not talking about a mass produced item.

It shouldn't be forgotten that a painter gives a piece of their soul when they create a work. So the letting go first starts with the painter. This can be a difficult process.

I have trouble selling my works, as they are my children. And I am always terrified they will end up unloved.

I have beautiful things hoarded in my closet and have often thought that we should start a blogger exchange network.
Anonymous said…
Hi! I've been an art dealer for over 12 years now an happen to represent Jennifer Davis' work. Believe me, it's a question that comes up all the time and for various reasons beyond matching decor - inheritedart through death, no more wall space, divorce, need cash etc.

Obviously, each reason will have a slightly different answer, but to address the issue of changing taste specifically, just like artists' styles grow change and evolve over time, so your tastes change too. However, what is so exciting about Collecting art, is to be able to see that process unfold over time. You may not feel that particular pieces of your collection are as "en vogue" or appelaing to you right now, but you may be thrilled to have them many years from now as part of a bigger collection.

I can (and do!) argue that I have many pieces that don't fit in my small Boston apartment. However, I've had art-world friends argue that if I truly loved the work, I would have to live with it and could hang salon style. True. But it's not my aesthetic and feels too "noisey" for me. I need space and time to have quiet dialog with individual paintings. Do I LOOOVE visiting my friends' homes who hang salon style -you bet!

So what to do with art that simply does not "fit" anymore? I lend my art to family and friends. I know, sounds insane to lend something that valuable, but I always remind myself of the joy I get from living with original art. To be able to share that joy is an extraordinary experience. Well, just look at what I do for a living ;-)

Stephanie Walker
Walker Contemporary


ps- sorry for crazy typos. all from an iPhone.
Anonymous said…
As an inveterate horder i can honestly say that i've got more artwork "not" on the walls, than i do "on" the walls. I've got stuff stashed in closets, in under the bed, the garage, the attic. It's all lovely, but as with everything in life, your tastes change. Like your orange phase.

If you have the space, store it. You may hit another orange phase 3 years down the line and regret your choice to part with the art. Otherwise and since you are obviously a "much" neater person than myself. Sell it on e-bay or etsy or a consignment shop, or swap with a friend. I gift stuff all the time.

If you have a good working relationship/friendship with the artist, discuss it with him/her. It is perfectly within your purvue to sell it, you own it, you paid for it, it wasn't a rental. ^_^

I just parted with a painting i'd done my (now ex) husband. I painted it for him, it was his Christmas present 30 years ago, so i gave it to him in the divorce. But, i did ask that if he decided he "didn't" want it, i wanted it back. He agreed.
Some galleries and museums have an Art resale program which resales work that you want to give to a good home. I know the Portland Museum of Art Renters Gallery does this :) love your blog.
MelanieO said…
Is art better displayed by someone who loves it, or stored in a box by someone who used to love it? I think you know the answer. You should sell it, assuming you bought the art. Artwork that was given to you as a gift by the artist is trickier & you may want to store it to be displayed later when you love it again. Selling art you no longer love helps the artist by providing exposure to more people and possibly selling new pieces to new fans.
Brigitte said…
I would think the best approach is mixed. First, decide if any of your art would have meaning for someone close to you or bring them joy. Gift those pieces.

Take a few that you still love and pop them in a closet to swap with your current display.

I think it would be nice if you gave away a few pieces here or at Decor8, or even better, auctioned some off for a cause you believe in. (am I too bold to suggest that?)

And sell the rest.
Rita Vindedzis said…
I think it's fantastic that you have such an extensive art collection and it's true that one's taste and circumstance change over their lifetime.

As an artist myself, I do not get upset when I find out that a painting that someone purchased from me years ago has been sold. In fact, I've seen 1 older piece of mine on ebay. Might I suggest putting the paintings that you don't want into storage. It might be that in a few years you will feel different about them and want them back on display.

If you're sure that you really can't live with them any more you could donate them to a charity that could re-sell them and use the money, or gift them to a friend that you know would love them. If these options don't work for you then try ebay, yard sales, or consignment shops.
Isis said…
hi holly!

i think there is nothing offending in selling some of your art collection. art is sold and resold all the time. that is how the art market works.
as for the artist itself, i think it can also be a very positive thing, this way your art will be enjoyed by more people!
ArtShades said…
I'm totally with Shanon. Sell the ones that no longer make you happy and don't feel guilty. I am sure there would be many interested in buying original works - especially those who missed out on it in the first place when you bought it!

It's all the prints from long ago which I no longer like that I am stuck with....

Popular Posts